Pay When Paid vs Pay If Paid: Can the GC Legally Hold Your Money?
Pay when paid is a subcontract clause that lets the general contractor wait until the owner pays before it pays you. Courts in many states read it as a timing rule: the general contractor can delay payment for a reasonable time, but it still owes you if the owner never pays. Pay if paid goes further. It makes the owner's payment a condition of your payment, so if the owner never pays, the general contractor may never owe you. Some states ban pay if paid outright.
| Pay when paid | Pay if paid | |
|---|---|---|
| What it controls | When you get paid | Whether you get paid |
| If the owner never pays | Generally, the GC still owes you after a reasonable time | The GC may owe nothing, where the clause is enforced |
| Typical wording | "within 7 days after receipt of payment from the owner" | "receipt of payment by contractor is a condition precedent to payment to subcontractor" |
| Enforceability | Widely enforced as a timing clause | Unenforceable in some states by statute, enforced in others if the wording is clear |
Can the GC legally hold your money?
For a while, yes, if your subcontract has a pay-when-paid clause. Indefinitely, usually not. The answer turns on three things: the exact wording, your state's law, and whether the owner's nonpayment is your fault. A clause that only says when payment is due is read as pay when paid. To create pay if paid, most courts require clear words that the subcontractor takes the risk of the owner not paying, such as "condition precedent."
States that limit pay-if-paid clauses
Two examples read from the statute text today:
| State | What the statute says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| North Carolina | Payment by the owner to a contractor is not a condition precedent for payment to a subcontractor, and an agreement to the contrary is unenforceable | N.C. Gen. Stat. 22C-2 (read 2026-11-01) |
| Wisconsin | Voids provisions that make payment from a party without a contract with the subcontractor a condition precedent to the prime contractor's payment to the subcontractor, but allows provisions that delay payment until the prime contractor is paid | Wis. Stat. 779.135(3) (read 2026-11-01) |
Other states limit these clauses by statute or court decision, and some enforce clear pay-if-paid wording. Before you sign, have the payment clause checked under the law of the project's state.
Pay if paid and your lien rights
A payment clause between you and the general contractor does not erase your lien or bond rights. Even where pay if paid is enforced, a mechanics lien against the property or a claim on the payment bond can still reach the money. The catch is the deadline: the lien and bond claim windows keep running while you wait for the owner to pay the GC. Use the lien calculator to see how many days are left.
How to protect yourself under either clause
- Strike or edit "condition precedent" language before you sign, or add a backstop: payment due no later than a fixed number of days after your invoice, whether or not the owner has paid.
- Send preliminary notices on every job. They keep your lien rights alive if the clause leaves you waiting.
- Ask whether the owner has paid. If the GC has been paid and still holds your money, the clause no longer protects it. Send a payment demand letter.
- Send a notice of intent to lien before your deadline. See the notice of intent to lien guide.
- Keep retainage on your radar. It is often held under the same clause. See retainage in construction.
LienWarden counts every lien and bond claim date from your project dates and drafts the demand letter when a payer stalls. Your first project is free. Start free.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between pay when paid and pay if paid?
Pay when paid controls timing: the general contractor may wait for the owner's payment, but generally still owes you after a reasonable time. Pay if paid makes the owner's payment a condition, so the general contractor may never owe you if the owner never pays.
Is pay if paid legal?
It depends on the state. North Carolina makes pay-if-paid agreements unenforceable (N.C. Gen. Stat. 22C-2), and Wisconsin voids them while allowing clauses that only delay payment (Wis. Stat. 779.135(3)). Other states enforce clear pay-if-paid wording.
How long can a general contractor hold payment under pay when paid?
Usually only a reasonable time, unless the contract sets a specific number of days. Courts in many states will not let a pay-when-paid clause delay payment forever.
Does a pay-if-paid clause stop me from filing a mechanics lien?
Generally no. The clause is between you and the general contractor. Your lien against the property and your payment bond rights are separate, but their deadlines keep running, so track them with the lien calculator.
What does PWP mean in payment terms?
PWP is short for pay when paid: you are paid after the party above you is paid.
Stop chasing invoices. Start collecting.
LienWarden computes every lien deadline in all 50 states from your project dates, then drafts and delivers the demand letters and notices — email included with paid plans, certified mail $19 flat. Your first active project is free.
Start free — no card requiredUse LienWarden free
Your first active project is free. LienWarden computes every notice and lien deadline in all 50 states from your project dates and drafts the documents.
Use LienWarden free →